By GREGORY R. NORFLEET
MT. VERNON — The Fifth District Appellate Court last week threw out a class-action lawsuit against microchip giant Intel Corp. that was approved by a Madison County circuit court.
In an 11-page ruling, a three-justice panel found that the case should have been filed in California and that there are not enough connections to Illinois to justify a case here, instead.
Madison County’s court system was heavily criticized in the 2004 Illinois Supreme Court race as a “judicial hellhole” that attracted numerous class-action lawsuits and then awarded huge monetary damages to plaintiffs. Those accusations have been leveled again this year in the race for the open seat of the Fifth District Appellate Court.
In the case of Barbara’s Sales Inc. et al v. Intel and Hewlett-Packard Co., Justice Richard Goldenhersh ruled that the plaintiff’s argument that the Pentium 4 processor is no better than the Pentium III should be filed in California because that’s Intel’s headquarters.
With Justices Melissa Chapman and Terrance Hopkins concurring, the court used a six-point test to render its ruling. It found that, while Intel microprocessing chips are sold in products throughout the 50 states, California has multiple ties to this case not found anywhere else.
California is where the chips are both designed and manufactured, to start, and the marketing strategy to sell the chips — with the claim the chips were far superior to even its own Pentium III — was developed there as well, the court ruled.
“With this in mind, we conclude that California’s interest in the conduct of Intel is the most significant,” read the ruling.
“We find that California has the most significant relationship to the occurrence and to the parties,” wrote the court. “California law, not Illinois law, is applicable. Accordingly, we vacate the order of the circuit court of Madison County regarding class certification.”
The ruling was issued July 25.
By GREGORY R. NORFLEET
Stuff the Bus campaign begins
MT. VERNON — A five-week campaign to collect school supplies for local schoolchildren will begin on Friday. United Way of South Central Illinois has announced its Stuff the Bus kickoff campaign will coincide with the organization's Day of Action. DaContinued ...
Jaycees cleaning out train depot
MT. VERNON — A longtime civic organization — Mt. Vernon Jaycees — is disbanding, and club members are conducting one last project this weekend to cap off its 67-year legacy. A public rummage sale will be held at noon on Saturday and Sunday at the clContinued ...
Continental Tire celebrates expansion
MT. VERNON — Continental Tire the Americas celebrated a milestone on Tuesday with a beam signing ceremony on its newest expansion. "CTA Mt. Vernon has always had the support of state and local officials," plant manager Benny Harmse said. "... I am cContinued ...
MVTHS weighs purchase offers
MT. VERNON – Mt. Vernon Township High School is now considering three offers to buy portions of its campus. Only one of those offers has reached the stage where a cost figure has been announced. That is the offer to purchase the parking areas adjacenContinued ...
Naming rights granted for new theater
MT. VERNON – The Schweinfurth Foundation has been granted lifetime naming rights for the new proposed Mt. Vernon Township High School theater. School officials say Schweinfurth has donated roughly $510,000 to the school over the years for arts prograContinued ...
- D80 wants cameras at Primary Center
- Improvements slated for Lincoln Park
- Heritage Gala draws a crowd
- Asbestos removal bids in for Armory
- Wolfstock Festival canceled
- Weekly Record
- Delatore pleads guilty to exploitation
- Merger won't hurt districts
- Relay For Life
- Sears announces Mt. Vernon store closure
- Stuff the Bus campaign begins