Mt. Vernon Register-News

Local

April 30, 2009

Villani election lawsuit to proceed

By TESA CULLI

tesa.culli@register-news.com

MT. VERNON — The lawsuit brought by Nicole Villani challenging the Nov. 4, 2008 election results in the Jefferson County State’s Attorney race and alleging voter fraud will move forward after a motion to dismiss the lawsuit was denied.

Villani, who was a candidate for Jefferson County State’s Attorney, filed the election contest petition asking for a full and complete recount of all ballots and votes that were cast in the Nov. 4 election after a discovery recount allegedly showed marked ballots and individual voters who were allegedly ineligible to vote. According to official election results, Villani lost the race by 69 votes. Named in the lawsuit are Jefferson County State’s Attorney Jeff Bradley and Jefferson County Clerk Connie Simmons.

Last month local attorney Jim Hanson, who is representing Simmons, argued for dismissing Villani’s lawsuit on the grounds the complaint as written doesn’t follow the Illinois Code of Civil Procedures.

However, Judge Mark L. Shaner ordered the case to go forward at this time. In his decision, Shaner noted case law which states that, “... while the pleadings in contest proceedings are not required to comply with strict technical rules applicable in civil actions there should be such strictness as will prevent the setting aside of the acts of sworn officials without adequate and well defined cause.”

“The court finds these objections do not require striking or dismissing in the present case,” Shaner wrote. “The court believes the complained of paragraphs and allegations are not so convoluted as to make answering them unreasonable difficult.”

Shaner did order the terms “and other provisions” and “no less than” used in Villani’s allegations should be stricken.

“There is no reason that Petitioner shouldn’t know which provisions of the election code she believes were violated and no reason respondents should be required to speculate,” Shaner stated. “... use of the term ‘no less than’ in several paragraphs and with several numbers is ambiguous. It is not clear to the court if petitioner is alleging ‘at least’ or is emphasizing the actual number.”

According to court information, depositions of election judges in Mt. Vernon 12 precinct will be held next week. In three weeks, the court is expected to set a date to hear arguments in Bradley’s motion for summary judgment in the case.

Text Only
Local
  • Principal shares information about school

    MT. VERNON – City Schools District 80 Primary Center Principal Shannon Marler provided the District 80 Board of Education with an update on the school at the latest board meeting.

    February 11, 2012

  • Check Bluford students collect donation

    BLUFORD — There probably hasn’t been much loose change jingling in parents’ pockets who have children attending Bluford Grade and High Schools the last three weeks.

    February 11, 2012 1 Photo

  • CASA Men Cooking for CASA winners

    MT. VERNON — The first-ever Men Cooking for CASA fundraiser officially came  to a close Thursday afternoon.

    February 10, 2012 1 Photo

  • Brehm offering free computer classes

    MT. VERNON — C.E. Brehm Memorial Library is offering free computer classes through a grant funded by Illinois Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity.

    February 10, 2012

  • Teachers receive grants

    MT. VERNON — Ten City Schools District 80 teachers recently received grants from the District 80 Foundation.

    February 10, 2012

  • Overdose immunity law to go into effect

    MT. VERNON — Gov. Pat Quinn signed a law that will go into effect June 1, which will give immunity from prosecution to people who call 911 to report drug overdoses.

    February 10, 2012

  • Heart Night Second Women’s Heart Night held

    MT. VERNON — A sea of ladies dressed in red descended upon Cedarhurst Center for the Arts on Thursday for the second Women’s Heart Night.

    February 10, 2012 1 Photo

  • Evening of Jazz at Cedarhurst Valentine weekend

    The 6th Annual Valentine Weekend Jazz Concert at Cedarhurst will be held Saturday, featuring the Loren Golden Ensemble.
    "This is the sixth year for the Evening of Jazz at Cedarhurst,” Sarah Sledge, Cedarhurst's Communications Director noted. "It's always a popular event when we pair jazz music with the Valentine theme."
    Golden, an attorney by profession, is a talented pianist who frequently performs with the Elgin Community College Jazz Ensemble, inormation states.  A pianist since the age of four, his love of the arts has inspired his continued involvement with music. Golden has enjoyed playing piano in variety shows, summer theatre, and clubs such as the Playboy Clubs in Chicago and Lake Geneva.

    February 9, 2012

  • District 80 receives recognition

    City Schools District 80 received a 3.8 out of a possible 4 points on its 2012 Financial Profile Designation from the Illinois State Board of Education.
    This is the second year in a row the district has received the “financial recognition” category from the state board; the district received the same score as 2011.

    February 9, 2012

  • WILLIAMS JCAAHC highlights citizens

    Karl Williams, the inbound manager at Walgreen’s Distribution, has worked there for 39 years, 20 of which has been in the King City.
    Debbie Kendrick-Hopgood followed in her grandmother’s and father’s footsteps as the head of Kendrick Paper Stock Company, and has worked there since 1980.

    February 9, 2012 1 Photo